News

American Myths-tory

Our national need for stories outweighs our hunger for the truth

Comments (2)
Tuesday, November 03, 2009
Henry Wadsworth Longfellow more or less created the Paul Revere myth in 1861.

They say history is written by the winners, but it's written by myth-makers too — if that's not a redundancy. In recent weeks, while researching a publishing project on the myths of American history, I have combed through an unending supply of stories that, upon closer scrutiny, simply do not hold, or even add, up.

Even the "discovery" and naming of America is shrouded in myth. Although Columbus's myth was thoroughly deconstructed in 1992, the quincentennial of his "discovery" of America, here it is 17 years later and the myth is as strong as ever — government workers even get a day off with pay in his name. Amerigo Vespucci, for whom America was named, published fraudulent letters in his lifetime that inflated his maritime feats, bringing him to the attention of a mapmaker whose clerical error — printing "America" on an uncharted land mass — resulted in our name. Samuel Eliot Morison wrote, "Here's to you, Amerigo. Liar though you were, you made three long transatlantic voyages, wrote entertainingly about them, and played your cards so cleverly as to be elected to the exclusive club of the immortals."

If the very foundations of this nation are constructed on such sandy ground ... well, you catch my drift, I hope.

Two things struck me about this need to create stories out of whole cloth or national heroes larger than events in which they participated.

First, the reality of history is so much more rich and interesting than the myths and lies that too often supplant it. Take Paul Revere's ride. The myth says Revere rode from Boston to Concord to warn the sleeping villagers that "the British were coming!" While it's true Revere made a "midnight ride" on April 18, 1775, his goal was not to sound a wide alarm. Historian David Hackett Fischer wrote, "Revere's primary mission was not to alarm the countryside. His specific purpose was to warn Samuel Adams and John Hancock, who were thought to be the objects of the expedition." Revere was one of three riders sent out from the city for this purpose and after independence was largely forgotten. His myth was created by Henry Wadsworth Longfellow's, "The Midnight Ride of Paul Revere," published in The Atlantic in 1861. Fischer noted, "As an historical description of Paul Revere's ride, the poem was grossly, systematically, and deliberately inaccurate." Fischer's Historians' Fallacies, should be a standard reference book for all authors planning to write the history of the Clinton-Bush-Obama years.

Second, the swiftness with which Americans are willing to accept, believe and disseminate myths would be touching if it wasn't so dangerous. Take the sinking of the battleship Maine, the immediate cause of the Spanish-American War. The explosion was caused by a fire in the ammunition hold, not by Spanish sabotage. Doesn't matter; we wanted the war, so Hearst sold the sabotage myth to the American people, they quickly bought it hook, line and sinker, and we ended up an empire.

Or take the alleged firing on U.S. troops stationed — provocatively — at the mouth of the Rio Grande River, Pres. Polk's excuse to start the Mexican War; or the roundly debunked Gulf of Tonkin incident which Pres. Johnson twisted to initiate the Vietnam War; or the various excuses used to justify invasions of Latin American countries from Cuba to Granada, or assassinate foreign leaders. The myth of the Iraq war will, no doubt, feature images of Bush with a bullhorn atop the rubble at Ground Zero, Saddam's massive nuclear stockpile and "mission accomplished."

With cable television, satellite radio and the Internet instantly spinning events, the myth-making machinery has never been stronger than it is now. On and on it goes and where it stops nobody knows.

 

Comments (2)
Post a Comment
Myth Modifies Myth

Alen Bisbort may be stating the truth in his article "American Myths-tory" (November 5, 2009), which is ironic since he argues that the truth hardly matters. If truth cannot trump myth, then writers must employ "truthiness" in its stead. Take, for instance Laura Ingalls Wilder, who chanelled her disillusionment toward the New Deal by writing that family and community (rather than Mr. Roosevelt and his big government) would get people through hard times. Say what you will about her politics; Wilder's "Little House" books also helped counter prevailing myths about the Old West at the time: that women had no role in settling this country, that it was all cowboys, guns, gold miners and railorads. So mythmaking can cut both ways; it's just P.R. taking the long view.
Posted by Wayne Jebian on 11.5.09 at 5.20
Will global warming fall into the same myth-making
machinery story?
just a thought.
Posted by John Bodnar on 1.10.10 at 20.30
Leave this field empty Name*:

Email*:

URL:

Comment:

All comments must adhere to our Terms & Conditions of Use.

Find it Here:
keyword:
search type:
search in:

« Previous   |   Next »
Print Email RSS feed

The Devil in the Details
Sure, Lieberman pissed off liberals by killing the public option. But there’s more to the story. Here’s the whole truth and what it means for Connecticut.
Immobilized
A pre-schooler in the West Hartford public school system is made to wear a weight vest for being too wiggly
No Sex Offenders
Greenwich ponders restricting where registered sex offenders can go
Nightmare Memory
A witness to Eugenio DeLeon Vega’s slaying says she didn’t say what she said
Cuffed in Pittsburgh
A former Army medic says police stripped him of his insignia and patches during the G-20 summit
Freegan Out
From second-hand clothes to foraging in fields to grabbing dinner out of trash bins, freegans try to take as little as possible from the consumer world
Water World
Will the new expanded bottle deposits mean more money flooding into the state? Critics doubt it.
Crime and Punishment
Round-up of local crimes